Does Coffee Mate Creamer Need to Be Refrigerated? (All to Know!)

Coffee Levels is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

As you prepare your morning coffee, a thought crosses your mind – does Coffee Mate creamer need to be refrigerated? The answer to this question depends on the creamer you use. Let’s dive into the world of coffee creamers and learn how to preserve their freshness and flavor best.

Liquid Coffee Mate creamers require refrigeration to maintain their freshness and prevent spoilage. After opening, storing them at a cool temperature, preferably near the back of your refrigerator where temperatures are more stable, is important. On the other hand, powdered Coffee Mate creamers can be safely stored in a cool, dry place without refrigeration.

Knowing how to store your Nestle Coffee Mate creamer is essential for enjoying that perfect cup of coffee. Whether you’re a fan of liquid or powdered creamers, following proper storage guidelines is crucial to ensure your mornings start with a delicious and worry-free sip.

Should You Put Coffee Mate Creamer in the Fridge?

Good news! Whether or not you should refrigerate your Coffee Mate creamer depends on the type you have. Let’s find out which creamer types need to stay chilled and which don’t.

Liquid Creamer – If you have a bottle of Coffee Mate liquid creamer, then you need to put it in the fridge. This will help it stay fresh and maintain its delicious flavors. So, after you’ve opened it, keep it chilled to ensure you make your morning coffee with a rich and fresh taste!

Powdered Creamer – If you use a powdered Coffee Mate creamer, you do not need to refrigerate it. Powdered creamers have a longer shelf life, and they can stay fresh without needing any refrigeration. Remember to store your powdered creamer in a cool, dry place to maintain its quality.

In short, liquid Coffee Mate creamers should always be stored in the fridge, while powdered ones can stay in your pantry. Keep this difference in mind when enjoying your next cup of coffee with a delightful Coffee Mate creamer.

Do You Need to Refrigerate Coffee Mate Creamer?

Unopened Coffee Mate Creamer

When it comes to unopened Coffee Mate creamer, refrigeration requirements depend on the type of creamer you have. Generally, unopened liquid creamers should be stored in the fridge.

However, unopened powdered creamers can be stored in a cool, dry place without refrigeration.

Opened Coffee Mate Creamer

Once you have opened your Coffee Mate creamer, taking proper storage precautions is essential. For opened liquid creamers, you should always keep them in the refrigerator to maintain their quality and freshness.

On the other hand, opened powdered creamers can still be stored in a cool, dry place, but seal the container tightly to keep the powder fresh.

Coffee Mate Liquid vs Powdered Creamer

Regarding Coffee Mate creamer, there are different types: liquid and powdered. The key difference in their storage requirements lies in whether they need to be refrigerated or not.

  • Liquid Coffee Mate creamer must be refrigerated when unopened and opened to maintain its quality and prevent spoilage.
  • Powdered Coffee Mate creamer does not require refrigeration. It can be stored in a cool, dry place, away from heat and humidity.

Factors That Affect the Lifetime of Creamer

Several factors come into play regarding the lifetime of coffee creamer. Let’s dive into some of these factors to help you keep your creamer fresh for longer.

Expiration date: Always pay attention to the expiration date on your coffee creamer. Make sure to use it before the date listed on the package, as using it past the expiration date can result in a spoiled product and may affect the taste of your coffee.

Ingredients: The ingredients in your creamer play a role in its shelf life. For example, liquid Coffee Mate creamers must be refrigerated once opened, as they can spoil when exposed to warm temperatures for extended periods.

Powdered Coffee Mate creamers can be stored in a cool, dry place and do not require refrigeration.

Position in the fridge: If you’re using a creamer that needs refrigeration, place it towards the back of the fridge where the temperature is more consistent. This will help maintain the quality of the creamer and slow down any spoilage.

Whether they’re open or not: An unopened Coffee Mate creamer can be stored at room temperature, but it needs to be refrigerated once opened. This helps prolong the freshness of the creamer, ensuring great-tasting coffee every time.

When they sit out on your counter: If you’re using a creamer that requires refrigeration, don’t let it sit there too long. Drinking coffee prepared with creamer that has been sitting out for too long can lead to an undesirable taste or even spoilage. So, putting the creamer back in the fridge as soon as you’re done using it is important.

By keeping these factors in mind, you can ensure you’re enjoying delicious coffee with fresh creamer every time.

Shelf Life and Expiration

Determining Expiration Dates

When it comes to Coffee Mate creamer, both the powdered and liquid forms come with their own specific shelf life.

For the liquid Coffee Mate creamer, it’s always advised to refrigerate it after opening to ensure maximum freshness.

Sealed liquid creamers can last up to 15 days beyond the expiration date marked on the label while open, but properly stored ones can last between 10 to 15 days.

On the other hand, powdered creamers don’t need to be refrigerated and should be kept in a cool, dry place.

These have a much longer shelf life, making them a good choice for those who don’t use creamer as frequently.

Effects of Spoilage on Taste and Quality

If Coffee Mate creamers aren’t stored properly, their taste and texture can be compromised. Spoiled creamers can develop a sour or rancid smell and taste and a clumpy texture.

This could be due to exposure to heat or sunlight or simply because the creamer has expired.

Swapping flavors like French Vanilla or Hazelnut with a spoiled creamer can greatly impact the desired taste of your hot coffee.

To ensure the best taste and quality, you should always check the smell and texture of your creamer before adding it to your coffee.

Health Risks of Expired Coffee Mate Creamer

Even though many non-dairy creamers like Coffee Mate are primarily made from vegetable oil and corn syrup, these ingredients can still harbor bacteria when spoiled.

Consuming expired Coffee Mate creamer could pose some health risks, including potential foodborne illnesses. Common symptoms of foodborne illnesses include nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and sometimes even more severe complications.

So, it’s crucial to pay attention to the condition of your Coffee Mate creamer before using it. If it smells off, appears curdled, or has passed the expiration date, it’s best to dispose of it and purchase a new bottle or container.

By following proper storage guidelines and keeping an eye on expiration dates, you can ensure that your creamer remains safe and delicious to use.

Coffee Mate Creamer Storage Tips

Selecting the Right Storage Location

To maintain the freshness and flavor of your Coffee Mate creamer, choosing the right storage location is important.

For liquid coffee mate and non-dairy creamers, always store them in the refrigerator once opened, as they require a cold temperature to stay fresh.

However, coffee mate powdered creamer requires no refrigeration – keep it in a cool, dry place like your pantry or cupboard.

Check the label for any specific storage instructions if you’re using a lactose-free or shelf-stable creamer.

Proper Handling and Usage Tips

When using your Coffee Mate creamer, make sure to follow these guidelines to ensure the best flavor and quality:

  • Keep your creamer sealed when not in use to preserve its freshness.
  • Always shake your liquid coffee mate well before pouring it into your coffee.
  • Don’t use creamer past its expiration date, regardless of the type.
  • Note that ultra-pasteurization allows some creamers to be stored at room temperature until opened – but they must be refrigerated once opened.
  • If you’re trying new flavors, try buying small containers to prevent wastage if you don’t like a particular flavor.

Proper storage and handling will help your Coffee Mate creamer stay fresh and flavorful so you can enjoy it in your favorite cup of coffee.

How to Tell If Coffee Mate Creamer Has Spoiled?

If coffee creamer has gone bad, it might have a strange or sour smell, a different consistency or look mold, or an altered flavor.

If any of these things happen, throwing away the creamer and getting a new one is best.

How Long Is Coffee Mate Creamer Good After It’s Been Opened?

A liquid creamer should be used up within two weeks of being opened or by the date printed on the bottle. Most liquid creamers should be used within a week of being opened.

If dairy creamer sits in a fridge for too long, it will only be safe to eat for a short time. So keep both opened and closed dairy creamers in the fridge to make sure they don’t go bad.


When it comes to Coffee Mate creamers, the most important thing to do is check to see if the package has been opened or is still sealed. Following this rule of thumb will help ensure that you get the best product possible. Open containers should always be stored in the refrigerator to prevent food from going bad.

Powdered packages that have not been opened and are kept in a cool, dry place at room temperature will maintain their freshness until the expiration date. Creamers made with dairy products should be stored in the refrigerator, regardless of whether or not they have been opened.


Featured image credit: Coffee mate Facebook

Click here to view the Visual Story Version of this Article.